Marzo 1, 2012
almagenes:

thisisnotpsychology:

“Like most living creatures, the pigeon quickly associates the pressing of a lever with reward. But when a timer releases the seal automatically every 20 seconds,  the pigeon wonders, “What did I do to deserve this?” If it was flapping it’s wings at the time, it’ll continue to flap, convinced that it’s actions have a decisive influence on what happens. We call this Pigeon superstition.”
Mr. Nobody (2009)

But clearly, animals can’t be self conscious and intelligent. This particular phenomenon is simply a creature blindly associating cause with consequence, by trial and error, paired with survival logic (and wing-flapping, apparently), whereas humans have attained (and attuned) self-awareness and brain power by blindly associating cause with consequence, by trial and error, paired with survival logic and opposable thumbs (and bipedalism, too, that’s mighty important).
Also, God gave us the earth, it’s written in the books. You don’t see anywhere, “God gave the earth to humans and pigeons and other stupid creatures without opposable thumbs”, right? There clearly is a difference.
Case closed.
NB : In all seriousness, however, if you put this article on par with other similar behaviourist (?) discoveries of how we work, we might be able to theorize that our acute self-awareness and brain power might very well be the result of a confrontation between survival logic (if A often causes B and B leads to feeding time, then by repeating/refining action A, I get to survive some more) and guilt when logic fails to work (A didn’t cause B this time, what did I do wrong?)
Which would certainly explain why we are so crippled by guilt through mythic narratives like ‘the original sin’…

almagenes:

thisisnotpsychology:

“Like most living creatures, the pigeon quickly associates the pressing of a lever with reward. But when a timer releases the seal automatically every 20 seconds,  the pigeon wonders, “What did I do to deserve this?” If it was flapping it’s wings at the time, it’ll continue to flap, convinced that it’s actions have a decisive influence on what happens. We call this Pigeon superstition.”

Mr. Nobody (2009)

But clearly, animals can’t be self conscious and intelligent. This particular phenomenon is simply a creature blindly associating cause with consequence, by trial and error, paired with survival logic (and wing-flapping, apparently), whereas humans have attained (and attuned) self-awareness and brain power by blindly associating cause with consequence, by trial and error, paired with survival logic and opposable thumbs (and bipedalism, too, that’s mighty important).

Also, God gave us the earth, it’s written in the books. You don’t see anywhere, “God gave the earth to humans and pigeons and other stupid creatures without opposable thumbs”, right? There clearly is a difference.

Case closed.

NB : In all seriousness, however, if you put this article on par with other similar behaviourist (?) discoveries of how we work, we might be able to theorize that our acute self-awareness and brain power might very well be the result of a confrontation between survival logic (if A often causes B and B leads to feeding time, then by repeating/refining action A, I get to survive some more) and guilt when logic fails to work (A didn’t cause B this time, what did I do wrong?)

Which would certainly explain why we are so crippled by guilt through mythic narratives like ‘the original sin’…

  1. claudiagamino ha rebloggato questo post da thisisnotpsychology
  2. mortizjano ha rebloggato questo post da thisisnotpsychology
  3. katiakatiekate ha rebloggato questo post da thisisnotpsychology
  4. tall-and-lanky ha rebloggato questo post da thisisnotpsychology
  5. patrisaa ha rebloggato questo post da fuckyeahmrnobody
  6. casual-dreamer ha rebloggato questo post da pigeon-superstition
  7. nemocatcher ha rebloggato questo post da pigeon-superstition e ha aggiunto:
    I made a new blog dedicated to Mr. Nobody and Mr. Van Dormael’s other creations. It’s called “Pigeon Superstition”, you...
  8. pigeon-superstition ha rebloggato questo post da thisisnotpsychology
  9. maxmorphing ha rebloggato questo post da almagenes
  10. secretofadream ha rebloggato questo post da almagenes
  11. almagenes ha rebloggato questo post da asdavy e ha aggiunto:
    But clearly, animals can’t be self conscious and intelligent. This particular phenomenon is simply a creature blindly...
  12. asdavy ha rebloggato questo post da fuckyeahmrnobody
  13. godofmischeif ha rebloggato questo post da fuckyeahmrnobody
  14. the-distant-drums ha rebloggato questo post da monviemylife
  15. ninadees ha rebloggato questo post da fuckyeahmrnobody
  16. xx-rapunzel-xx ha rebloggato questo post da fyeahpigeons
  17. alrighght ha rebloggato questo post da unfucked
  18. unfucked ha rebloggato questo post da thisisnotpsychology
  19. bacchanalian-merrow ha rebloggato questo post da id0ntev3n
  20. carsoncomedy ha rebloggato questo post da fuckyeahmrnobody
  21. darklydreaming108 ha rebloggato questo post da fuckyeahmrnobody
  22. isinyourhead ha rebloggato questo post da thisisnotpsychology
  23. missobliviate ha rebloggato questo post da fuckyeahmrnobody
  24. rogueleader5 ha rebloggato questo post da imcompotent
  25. with-out-wax ha rebloggato questo post da afuturefossilfuel
  26. orik ha rebloggato questo post da thisisnotpsychology
  27. 11126 ha rebloggato questo post da thishouseisemptynow
blog comments powered by Disqus